Short answer: it depends almost entirely on what you feed them. Chickens fed on bought grain are often close to break-even, or even a net calorie cost, once feed is properly accounted for -- you're essentially converting purchased grain into eggs, at a loss. Chickens that forage a real share of their own diet, or are fed on kitchen scraps and garden waste that would otherwise go to compost, are a genuinely different calculation: real calories in, for very little purchased input.
Last updated 5 November 2026
On This Page
All 18 Resilience Gardening guides in one printable 121-page PDF. See what's inside
The Question Isn't "Chickens or Not" -- It's "Fed How"
The honest calorie case for keeping chickens comes down almost entirely to what goes into them. A hen converts feed into eggs, but that conversion is never 100% efficient -- some of every calorie fed in is lost to the bird's own metabolism rather than turned into egg. If that feed is bought grain, you're paying (in money, and in the land that grain itself took to grow) for a conversion that loses calories along the way.
The calculation changes completely if a meaningful share of a chicken's diet comes from sources that would otherwise go to waste -- foraging on pasture or scraps, garden and kitchen waste, spoiled produce not fit for the table. None of that has an opportunity cost the way purchased grain does, so chickens fed this way genuinely add calories to a household's food supply rather than converting existing calories at a loss.
There's also real value outside the raw calorie calculation: manure that builds soil fertility for free, pest control from free-ranging birds, and a source of protein that doesn't rely on refrigeration the way stored meat does. This site's livestock and other food sources step lets you model your own animals -- including whether their feed costs leave them net positive or net negative for your household's calorie plan.
What Chickens Actually Give You
A flock of laying hens gives you three things: eggs, meat and manure. All three matter in a self-sufficient plan, but eggs are the headline.
- Eggs. A good laying hen produces roughly 200 to 300 eggs in her first full year, depending on breed. Heritage and dual-purpose breeds often lay about 150 to 200. Laying drops in winter as the days shorten, and stops for a few weeks each autumn while the hen moults, and output falls a little each year as she ages.
- Meat. Surplus cockerels, hens past their best and dedicated meat birds all end up in the pot. An old laying hen is tough, and best slow-cooked or made into stock.
- Manure. Chicken manure is rich in nitrogen and one of the best soil boosters you can make. Compost it first, or let it age for several months before it goes near crops. See building healthy soil without fertiliser.
- Pest control and waste recycling. Hens eat slugs, insects and kitchen scraps, and turn them into eggs and manure.
How many hens do you need? As a rough guide, aim for about one hen per person for a steady supply, and more if the household eats eggs freely or you want to preserve some. Remember that output varies through the year.
| Household | Hens for a steady egg supply | Roughly how many eggs a week in good laying |
|---|---|---|
| 1 to 2 people | 3 hens | About 15 to 18 |
| A family of 4 | 5 to 6 hens | About 25 to 35 |
| Family of 4 who also want a surplus | 8 to 10 hens | About 45 to 60 |
You do not need a cockerel for eggs. Hens lay perfectly well without one. You only need a cockerel if you want fertile eggs to hatch your own chicks.
The Calorie Maths, Worked Through
Our short answer at the top of the page says it depends on feed. Here is why, with rough numbers:
- A laying hen eats about 110 to 125 grams of feed a day, which is roughly 40 to 45 kilograms a year.
- One medium egg contains about 70 to 80 calories. A hen laying five eggs a week produces roughly 55 calories of egg a day.
- The 115 grams of layer feed she eats contains something like 300 calories of energy.
So the eggs return only a fraction of the energy fed in, roughly a sixth to a fifth. If that feed is wheat or maize you grew on land you could have used for human food, you would get more calories by eating the grain directly. That is the honest case against chickens as a pure calorie source.
The case for chickens rests on three things the simple sum leaves out:
- Feed that is not human food. Kitchen scraps, garden waste, weeds, slugs and insects, spoiled produce and what the hens find themselves cost you no human calories at all. Every calorie they get from these is a calorie gained.
- Egg quality. An egg is a compact, complete package of protein, fat and vitamins that is hard to get from a vegetable plot, especially fat, B vitamins and vitamin D.
- The by-products. Manure, pest control and the weeding and scratching they do over a bed between crops.
In short, chickens are worth keeping when they are fed largely from what you would not otherwise eat, and not worth it when they sit on a bag of bought grain. Our calculator's livestock and other food sources step lets you model this for your own household. For the bigger picture, see can you survive on vegetables alone?.
Housing, Safety and Daily Care
- A secure house. Plan roughly 0.4 square metres of indoor floor per bird, with perches, nest boxes (one for every three or four hens) and good ventilation without draughts.
- Outdoor space. As a minimum, around 1 square metre of run per bird, and much more is better. Moving the run onto fresh ground keeps it clean and gives hens fresh forage.
- Predator-proofing. Foxes, badgers, stoats, rats, dogs and birds of prey are the main threats. Shut the birds in every night, bury or skirt wire below ground, and use strong latches that a fox or raccoon cannot lift. Most losses happen because someone forgot to shut the door.
- Daily routine. Let them out in the morning, check water and feed, collect eggs, and shut them in at dusk. In total it takes a few minutes a day, plus a weekly clean and a more thorough clean-out now and then.
- Winter. Keep the house dry and draught-free. Hens cope well with cold if they are dry, but water can freeze, so check it daily. Extra artificial light can keep laying going through the winter, but many keepers prefer to let the hens rest.
- Health. Watch for mites, lice and worms, and for birds that are hunched, listless or not eating. Keep new birds apart for a few weeks before adding them to the flock.
Check local rules on keeping poultry, and on bird flu. In an outbreak, authorities in many places may require birds to be housed or registered, and wild water birds can carry the disease, so good biosecurity matters, especially for ducks and geese.
Choosing Breeds, and Keeping the Flock Going
There are three broad types of chicken, and the right choice depends on what you want and how self-reliant you want to be.
| Type | Examples | Eggs | Meat | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hybrid layers | Many commercial brown and white layers | Highest, often 250 to 300+ a year | Poor, light birds | Excellent for the first one or two years, then decline. Their chicks do not come true, like F1 seed. |
| Dual-purpose heritage breeds | Sussex, Orpington, Plymouth Rock, Wyandotte, Rhode Island Red | Good, roughly 150 to 250 a year | Decent table birds | Hardy and often good mothers. They breed true, so you can raise your own replacements. |
| Meat breeds | Fast-growing broilers and slower traditional crosses | Poor | Fast, heavy birds in a matter of weeks | Fast broilers grow quickly but suffer leg and heart problems. Slower birds do better outdoors. |
If self-sufficiency is the aim, heritage breeds are the equivalent of open-pollinated seed. They breed true, so you can hatch your own replacements, usually under a broody hen, which takes about 21 days, with no need to buy in each year. Hybrid layers produce more eggs but you will have to keep buying new pullets. See open-pollinated vs F1 hybrid for the same idea in plants.
To keep a flock going you need to replace birds every couple of years, since laying declines with age. Hatching a few chicks each spring from your own hens, and eating the spare cockerels, keeps the cycle running.
Poultry at a Glance
Chickens are the all-rounder, but other birds may suit your land, climate or purpose better. These figures are rough, and vary widely with breed, season, feed and care.
| Bird | Eggs per year | Meat | Feed needs | Noise and space | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chicken | About 150 to 300 | About 1.5 to 3 kg dressed | Moderate | Moderate, roosters loud | The all-round choice |
| Bantam | About 80 to 200, small | Very little | Low | Low, small plots | Small gardens, broody hens |
| Duck | About 150 to 300, large | About 1.5 to 3 kg | Moderate, forage well | Medium noise, wet and messy | Wet climates, slugs, winter eggs |
| Goose | About 20 to 60, seasonal | About 4 to 6 kg plus fat | Low if on good grass | Loud, needs grazing land | Grass, fat and meat |
| Turkey | About 40 to 100, seasonal | About 5 to 10 kg or more | High | Medium, needs space | Large feasts, meat |
| Guinea fowl | About 60 to 100, seasonal | About 1 kg | Low if free-ranging | Very loud, roam widely | Pest and tick control, alarm |
| Quail | About 200 to 300, tiny | About 100 to 200 g | Low, but needs high-protein feed | Quiet, tiny footprint | Very small spaces, fast results |
| Pigeon | Not kept for eggs | Squab, about 250 to 450 g each | Low to moderate | Quiet, needs a loft | Steady meat, strong manure |
Bantams
Bantams are small chickens, some true miniatures with no large version (such as Pekin and Sebright) and some scaled-down versions of standard breeds. A bantam is typically a quarter to a half the weight of a standard hen.
- Pros. They eat much less, need less space, are gentler on the garden, and many are excellent broody mothers, which makes them ideal for hatching eggs from other birds, including ducks and standard chickens. They are the best choice for a small plot.
- Cons. Their eggs are small, usually around half the size of a standard egg, and there is almost no meat on them. Many lay fewer eggs, and some breeds fly well and need a covered run.
Verdict: bantams are great for limited space and as a hatching crew, but you would need roughly two bantam eggs to equal one standard egg, so plan for more birds if eggs are the main goal.
Ducks
Ducks are often the most underrated poultry for self-sufficiency. Some breeds are outstanding layers, they are tougher than chickens, and they love slugs and snails.
- Eggs. Good layer breeds such as Khaki Campbell and Indian Runner can lay around 250 to 300 eggs a year, and ducks tend to keep laying better through cold, dull weather than chickens. Duck eggs are larger and richer, and excellent for baking.
- Meat. Meat breeds such as Pekin and Aylesbury reach table size in about two months. Dual-purpose breeds like Rouen and Welsh Harlequin do both jobs reasonably well. Duck meat is rich and fatty.
- Hardiness. Ducks are generally hardier than chickens, less prone to disease, and cope well with wet weather and mud.
- Garden help. They are excellent slug and snail hunters, but trample young seedlings and will wreck soft crops, so keep them off beds with seedlings and lettuce.
- Water. They do not need a pond, but they do need water deep enough to dip their whole head in, to keep their eyes and nostrils clean. They are messy drinkers, so the area around their water turns to mud.
- Housing. A simple, well-ventilated, fox-proof shelter is enough, and they should be shut in every night. Ducks lay in the early morning, so keep them in until mid-morning for the eggs.
Verdict: an excellent choice in wet climates, for slug control and for reliable winter eggs. Muscovy ducks are a different species, much quieter, good foragers and good mothers, but lay fewer eggs, more seasonally.
Geese
Geese are grazers. They turn grass, which humans cannot eat, into meat, fat and feathers, which makes them the poultry that most reduces the feed bill, provided you have the grass.
- Feed. On good pasture, geese get most of their food from grazing, with extra grain only in winter and when they are growing or laying.
- Meat and fat. A goose can provide 4 to 6 kilograms of rich meat and a large amount of fat, which is hard to get from a garden and valuable for cooking and preserving. Geese are normally fattened and killed at around six months.
- Eggs. Large but few, and seasonal, typically a few dozen in the spring. Not a major egg source.
- Lifespan. Geese can live 15 to 20 years, so a breeding pair or trio can serve a household for a long time.
- Noise and temperament. Geese are loud and can be aggressive in the breeding season, which makes them excellent guards but poor neighbours in tight spaces.
- Space. They need considerably more room than chickens or ducks, ideally a paddock of grass, plus a pond or tub to bathe in. Geese can weed some established crops such as strawberries, fruit bushes and orchards, but they will eat young vegetables.
Verdict: a strong choice if you have grassland and want meat, fat and a watchdog. Not suitable for a small garden.
Turkeys
Turkeys are mainly a meat bird, and a large one, so they suit households with space and a reason to cook a big bird.
- Meat. Heritage turkeys such as Bronze, Bourbon Red, Norfolk Black and Narragansett typically reach 5 to 10 kilograms, though they take around six to seven months to mature. Commercial broad-breasted turkeys grow faster and bigger, but the commercial type cannot mate naturally, so you would have to buy poults every year.
- Breeding. Heritage breeds mate naturally and can be bred on your own plot. Turkey hens are sometimes poor mothers, so many keepers hatch the eggs under a broody chicken.
- Eggs. Turkeys lay edible eggs, but only a modest number, seasonally.
- Feed and space. They eat a lot and need a good deal of room to range.
- Health. Poults are delicate in their first weeks and need warmth and good starter feed. Keep turkeys away from chickens, because a disease called blackhead, carried by chickens, can kill turkeys.
Verdict: worthwhile only if you have space and want a big bird for the table. For most households, chickens and ducks give more food for less trouble.
Guinea Fowl
Guinea fowl are the watchdogs and pest controllers of the poultry yard. They are hardy and half wild, and they roam widely.
- Pest control. They eat huge numbers of insects, ticks, slugs and weed seeds, and they are good against crawling pests.
- Alarm. They are extremely noisy and raise the alarm at anything unusual, which suits a rural plot but not a close neighbour.
- Eggs and meat. The eggs are small with very hard shells, laid mostly in spring and summer, and keep well. The meat is lean and gamey, similar to pheasant, though a bird gives only around a kilogram.
- Feed. They find most of their own food if allowed to range, so they are cheap to keep.
- Habits. They are flighty, like to roost high, often hide their nests and can be hard to confine. The young keets are delicate in the first weeks.
Verdict: best as a free-ranging working bird on larger plots, for insect and tick control, with eggs and meat as a bonus.
Quail
Quail, usually Coturnix or Japanese quail, are the smallest domesticated egg birds, and the best answer for a household with almost no space. They grow fast and need very little.
- Speed. Coturnix quail mature quickly. They can start laying at around 6 to 8 weeks old, far sooner than chickens at roughly 5 months, so a flock gives results within a season.
- Eggs. A good hen can lay close to an egg a day, roughly 200 to 300 a year. The eggs are tiny, so about three to five equal one hen egg, but they are rich and very good eaten whole, boiled, pickled or in baking.
- Meat. Birds can be eaten at around 8 weeks, but there is little on one, perhaps 100 to 200 grams. Spare males and older hens are usually the ones eaten.
- Feed. They eat very little, around 20 to 30 grams a day each, but they need a high-protein feed, such as a game-bird or quail ration, so they are harder to feed from scraps and garden waste alone than chickens.
- Space. Quail can be kept in raised hutches, or in a floor pen in a shed or garage. Plan on roughly 0.1 to 0.2 square metres per bird, and give them a low roof, since they shoot upward when startled.
- Warmth and light. They are sensitive to cold and draughts, and for steady laying they like about 14 hours of light a day. They need a dry, draught-free shelter in cold weather.
- Breeding. Keep one male for every three to five females if you want fertile eggs. Eggs take about 17 to 18 days to hatch, and the chicks are tiny and need a heated brooder for the first couple of weeks.
- Lifespan. Laying falls off after the first year or so, so a flock needs replacing regularly. A quick hatch each year keeps it going.
Verdict: the best choice where space is very tight or you want fast results. They give a lot of eggs for very little room, but do not expect much meat, and you will need a supply of protein-rich feed.
Pigeons
Domestic pigeons are one of the oldest sources of home-raised meat. Medieval dovecotes supplied manor houses with fresh meat all winter. The meat comes from squab, the young birds, which are taken just before they fledge.
- How it works. A pair mates for life and raises young over and over through the year. Both parents feed the squab, first on a special "crop milk" and then on grain, so you are not hand-rearing anything.
- Yield. A pair typically raises two squab per clutch and can manage many clutches a year, perhaps ten or more squab a year from each pair. Utility breeds such as King, Carneau and Texan Pioneer are bred for larger squab, though even these are small, perhaps 250 to 450 grams dressed.
- Feed. Roughly 30 to 40 grams of grain and seed a day per bird. Peas, wheat, maize and small seeds all suit them, and free-flying birds find part of their own food. They need grit and clean water.
- Housing. A dry, draught-free loft or dovecote, with a nest box for each pair, perches, and an aviary or landing area. Plan on at least 0.2 to 0.3 square metres of floor per pair, and more is better. Keep it clean and well ventilated.
- Manure. Pigeon droppings are very rich in nitrogen, and a prized fertiliser once composted.
- Cautions. Pigeons can carry diseases, including some that affect people, such as ornithosis, so wash your hands and wear a mask when cleaning out. Some diseases are notifiable, and keeping rules vary, so check local regulations and neighbour sensitivities before starting. Keep them confined if you do not want them to mingle with feral birds.
Verdict: a quiet, low-labour way to get a steady supply of dark, rich meat plus excellent manure, if you have the loft space and the local rules allow it. The yield per bird is small, so you need several pairs for it to matter.
Other Birds, and Why They Are Not Recommended
- Pheasants and partridges. These are game birds, mostly raised for release. They need aviaries, are prone to disease and cannibalism when crowded, and give little return for a household, and game-bird rules may apply.
- Peafowl. Ornamental, extremely loud and destructive to gardens. They are not practical as a food source.
- Swans. Wild swans are protected in many places, and swans are not kept for food.
- Ostriches and emus. They are very large, can be dangerous, and need big, strongly fenced land and specialist knowledge. They are not a realistic choice for a household food plan.
If you want one of these, research the local rules and the real workload first.
Which Poultry Suits You?
| Your situation | Good choice |
|---|---|
| Small garden, limited space | Bantams, or a few standard hens or ducks |
| A family wanting reliable eggs | Dual-purpose heritage chickens, plus a few ducks for winter eggs |
| Wet, slug-prone climate | Ducks |
| Plenty of grass and a wish for meat and fat | Geese, with ducks or chickens for eggs |
| Large plot and a rural setting | Add guinea fowl for pest control |
| A big plot and a taste for roast turkey | A few heritage turkeys, kept apart from the chickens |
| Aiming to breed your own replacements | Heritage chickens or ducks, with a broody hen or bantam to hatch them |
| Almost no space, such as a shed, garage or yard | Quail |
| A steady supply of small meat birds with little labour | Pigeons, if local rules allow |
Start with a small number of one type, learn their needs, and add others later. A mixed flock needs a little care: chickens and turkeys do not mix well, ducks make the ground wet, and geese can bully smaller birds.
Common Poultry Mistakes
- Leaving the door open at night. The single biggest cause of lost flocks.
- Overstocking. Too many birds in too little space leads to mud, disease and stress.
- Relying entirely on bought feed. It makes the sums poor and leaves you exposed if supply stops.
- Mixing the wrong species. Chickens and turkeys especially.
- Ignoring the neighbours. Roosters, geese and guinea fowl are loud.
- Not planning for winter. Short days mean fewer eggs, and frozen water and wet housing cause trouble.
- Buying more than you can care for. Start small and add birds as your confidence grows.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it worth keeping chickens for self-sufficiency?
It depends on whether you can feed them cheaply -- chickens fed on purchased grain are often close to break-even or even a net calorie cost once feed is accounted for, while chickens that forage a meaningful share of their own diet, or are fed on kitchen scraps and garden waste, can be a genuine net positive, providing eggs and eventually meat for relatively little ongoing land or purchased input.
Do chickens produce more calories than they cost to feed?
Only if their feed costs are kept low -- a hen fed entirely on bought grain converts that grain into eggs at a real calorie loss, so the calorie case for chickens depends heavily on how much of their diet comes from foraging, scraps and garden waste rather than purchased feed.
What do chickens add beyond calories?
Chickens contribute things a pure calorie calculation misses -- pest control, converting kitchen and garden waste that would otherwise be discarded, and manure that improves soil fertility for free, all of which matter for a genuinely self-sufficient system even when the raw calorie maths is close to break-even.
How many eggs does a hen lay a year?
Roughly 200 to 300 in the first year for a good laying hybrid, and about 150 to 200 for many heritage breeds. Output drops in winter, during the autumn moult and as the hen gets older.
Do I need a rooster to get eggs?
No. Hens lay without one. You only need a rooster if you want fertile eggs to hatch chicks.
How much space do chickens need?
As a rough guide, about 0.4 square metres of indoor floor and at least 1 square metre of run per bird. More space is better and keeps the ground cleaner.
Are ducks easier than chickens?
In many ways, yes. They are hardier, lay well in cold weather and eat slugs. But they are messy around water, trample seedlings and are best shut away at night like any other poultry.
Are geese worth keeping?
If you have grassland and want meat and fat, yes. They graze rather than rely on grain, live a long time and make good guards. They are loud, need plenty of room and are not suited to small gardens.
Can chickens and turkeys live together?
It is best to keep them apart. Chickens can carry a disease called blackhead which is often harmless to them but can kill turkeys.
What are bantams good for?
Small spaces and hatching eggs. They eat little, are gentle on the garden and many make excellent broody mothers, but their eggs are small and there is almost no meat.
Are guinea fowl worth keeping?
On a larger rural plot, yes, as free-ranging insect and tick controllers and as a loud alarm. They give small eggs and a little lean meat, but are noisy and roam widely.
Can I keep poultry through the winter without bought feed?
It is hard. Forage is scarce, so you need stored grain, root crops, squash, kitchen scraps or a feed crop. Geese on pasture and free-ranging guinea fowl need the least extra feed.
How do I store surplus eggs?
Keep them unwashed in a cool place, freeze beaten eggs, pickle them in vinegar, or use water glass. Unwashed eggs keep several weeks, and the other methods keep them for months.
Are quail worth keeping for eggs?
Yes, especially where space is tight. Coturnix quail start laying at around 6 to 8 weeks and can lay roughly 200 to 300 small eggs a year, though you need three to five of their eggs to equal one hen egg. They need a high-protein feed and a warm, draught-free shelter.
How much space do quail need?
Roughly 0.1 to 0.2 square metres per bird. They can be kept in raised hutches or in a floor pen in a shed or garage, with a low roof, since they fly straight up when startled.
Can you eat pigeons that you keep?
Yes. The meat comes from squab, the young birds, taken just before they fledge. Utility breeds such as King and Carneau give the largest squab, though they are still small, so you need several pairs for a worthwhile supply.
Are pigeons hard to keep?
They need little daily labour, since the parents raise the young, but they need a clean, dry loft and good hygiene. They can carry diseases, some of which affect people, and local rules and neighbour concerns vary, so check before starting.